What Your Workers' Comp Renewal Letter Isn't Telling You

---

Once a year, a workers' comp renewal letter lands on your desk. Most owners skim the new premium, sigh, and sign. That habit can cost you thousands.

Here is a quick example. Say your premium is $80,000 and your experience mod climbed from 0.95 to 1.10. That one change adds roughly $12,000 to your bill. If the mod moved because a claim was coded wrong or left open too long, you are paying $12,000 for a paperwork error. And you will pay it again next year if nobody catches it.

The number on the front page is the result. The reasons behind it are buried where most people never look.

The increase is on page two

A renewal letter is built to be signed, not studied. The premium is front and center. What moved it, your experience mod, a reclassification, a claim from two years ago, sits in the fine print or does not appear at all.

So you see the bill go up and assume that is just how it goes. But every dollar of that increase has a cause, and some of those causes can be challenged.

It helps to remember what the letter is for. It is a renewal offer, not a verdict. The price is what the carrier would like to charge. Whether it is the right price is a separate question, and it is yours to ask.

What to look for before you sign

Start with your experience mod. Did it change from last year? If so, find out why. A higher mod is the single most common reason a premium jumps.

The mod is simple at its core. It compares your claims to other companies your size in your industry. A 1.00 is average. Above 1.00, you pay extra. Below it, you get a discount. The catch: it is built from claims data, and claims data contains errors more often than you would think.

Next, check your class codes against what your people actually do. Codes drift over time as roles change and new people come on. An office worker's rate might be a few dimes per $100 of payroll. A warehouse worker's rate can be ten times that. One person sitting in the wrong code, year after year, adds up fast.

Then look at your claims. Carriers set aside money, called reserves, for claims that stay open. Those reserves count against your mod even if the money is never spent. A claim that healed months ago but was never closed can quietly raise your rate. A claim that was coded wrong can do the same.

These are the levers. Most owners never know they exist.

Why this matters every single year

A renewal is not a formality. It is the one moment each year when your cost structure is on the table. Sign without looking, and you lock in every mistake for another twelve months.

And the mistakes compound. A claim stays on your mod for three years. Miss an error this year and you do not pay for it once. You pay for it three times. Add whatever new issues show up, and a five-minute signature can turn into a five-figure habit.

The STK Group reads the renewal the way most owners cannot. We find what moved the number, what can be fixed, and what you should never have been charged in the first place. Then we show you what the same coverage costs with a big group next to it, so you go into the renewal with a plan instead of a pen.